Skip to main content
BPN Logo
Joe Mantello: Can We Forgive the Unforgivable? | Downstate, Wicked & Making Art

Can someone do something unforgivable and still deserve to be treated as human? What happens when an apology doesn’t bring closure—and what should theater ask us to confront?.. Read More

From the show: Tea Time with Mikayla Petrilla

55 mins
Nov 17

Featured Shows

About

Can someone do something unforgivable and still deserve to be treated as human? What happens when an apology doesn’t bring closure—and what should theater ask us to confront?

Three-time Tony Award-winning director and actor Joe Mantello joins Mikayla Petrilla for a thoughtful, candid conversation about Bruce Norris’s Downstate, recorded during Broadway previews for his production.

Together, they explore the play’s difficult questions about accountability, punishment, redemption, and the lasting impact of abuse. Joe discusses telling a story truthfully while leaving audiences room to wrestle with their own reactions—and why a work of art can stay with us long before we understand how we feel about it.

The conversation also follows Joe’s extraordinary creative life, from Angels in America to directing Wicked, his recent Tony-winning direction of Death of a Salesman, and the upcoming Broadway production of Small Mouth Sounds. He shares what he’s learned from collaborating with Laurie Metcalf, how he handles criticism, and why some of his most meaningful experiences haven’t been his biggest commercial successes.

Plus: Stephen Sondheim’s “I’m Still Here,” a surprising trip to Brokeback Mountain with Idina Menzel, and the balance between backstage access and preserving theatrical magic.

Warm, funny, and generous, Joe offers a perspective on making art—and giving yourself permission to try again.

Content note: This episode discusses child sexual abuse, trauma, and its aftermath in the context of Downstate, including plot details.

Follow Tea Time with Mikayla wherever you listen, and subscribe on YouTube for full video conversations. Find Mikayla on Instagram @mikaylapetrilla.

Part of the Broadway Podcast Network.

Transcript

Mikayla Petrilla (00:00)

Can someone do something unforgivable and still deserve to be treated as a human? What happens when an apology doesn't bring closure? And what do we do with the story that challenges who we're willing to feel compassion for? Welcome back to Tea Time with Michaela. Today I am joined by three-time Tony Award-winning director and actor Joe Mantello. From Angels in America to Wicked, Joe has helped shape so much of the theater we know and love.

This year he won his third Tony Award for directing Death of a Salesman, and he is also directing the upcoming Broadway production of Smallmouth Sounds. We sat down during Broadway previews for his production of Bruce Norris's Downstate, a play that brings the survivor face to face with the man who abused him, and asks deeply uncomfortable questions about accountability, redemption, and the limits of closure. Our conversation goes from those questions to the very personal business of making art.

Surviving criticism, trusting your instincts, finding collaborators who surprise you, and giving yourself permission to try again. There's Lori Metcalf, there's Sonnheim, and somehow there's Brokeback Mountain. And Joe is just as lovely. He is warm, funny, and so thoughtful. I really appreciated how open he shared what he's learned, what he believes, and what he's still figuring out. I left this conversation with a lot to think about, and I hope you do too. I am so happy to share it with you, so grab a cup.

This is tea time with Joe Mantello.

Mikayla (01:20)

Hey Joe, how you doing? Good, good. Good. I

Joe Mantello (01:20)

are you doing? I'm Galo, good, good. Good.

Mikayla (01:23)

wanna start talking about Downstate

it's been fascinating to revisit this conversation now that it's on Broadway. what fascinates me is that Bruce Norris asks us to hold two seemingly contradictory ideas at once that

Joe Mantello (01:25)

It's been fascinating to revisit this conversation now that it's on Broadway. what fascinates me is that Bruce Norris asks us to hold two seemingly contradictory ideas at once that

someone can have done something unforgivable and yet they are still deserving of humanity. So, in that way, what drew you to direct this? How did you find your way into this show and what

Mikayla (01:36)

Someone can have done something unforgivable and yet they are still deserving of humanity. So in that way, what drew you to direct this? How did you find your way into this show and what

drew you to the production?

Joe Mantello (01:47)

production?

I read the script years ago before it went into production because K Tod Freeman and I are old friends from drama school.

Mikayla (01:55)

school

and the role had been written.

Joe Mantello (01:56)

And the role had been written

for him. I believe the role had been written for him. It seems like it's been written for him. It's you know, it's fits him like a glove. And so he sent me the play, and I just really I responded really enthusiastically to it. As I I love Bruce's writing. and then it went on to have another production. and I saw it at Playwrights, I thought it was really good, and of course thought Kate Todd was amazing

Mikayla (02:00)

Seems like it's important for him. You know, it fits him like a glove. And so he sent me the play, and I just really I responded really enthusiastically to it. As I I love Bruce's writing. Yeah. and then it went on to have another production. and I saw it at Playwrights. I thought it was really good, and of course thought Kate Talley was amazing.

Joe Mantello (02:20)

and Fran whom I knew as well.

and then it came around this time I guess Bruce had the rights reverted to him after that production closed and

Mikayla (02:22)

and then it came around this time I guess Bruce had the rights reverted to him after that production closed and

Joe Mantello (02:29)

it was just presented to me as an idea and I'd always loved it, so I was like, Yeah, let's go. And you know, and and because the roles had been written for K Todd and for Fran, we obviously wanted to have them be a part of it, but it's it is a brand new funny you say that because I've heard

Mikayla (02:29)

was just presented to me as an idea and I'd always loved it, so yeah, let's go. And you know, and and because the roles had been written for K Todd and for Fran, we obviously wanted to have them be a part of it. Of course. It is a brand new production. Well funny you say that 'cause my partner

was like, K Todd has to win the Tony for this. He was like without even knowing where this production is going based on what I saw at Playwright. So I putting that into the universe. that would be great. That would be lovely.

Joe Mantello (02:46)

Todd has to win the Tony for this. He was like without even knowing where this production is going based on what I in Playwright. that into the universe. that would be great. That would be great. He's been around for a long time and always does

you know, he does exceptional work all the time. We just work together on Death of a Salesman. And

Mikayla (02:59)

You know, he does exceptional work all the time. We just work together on death of a salesman. Yes. And

but

Joe Mantello (03:05)

Yeah, we've been panels since drama school. We did

Mikayla (03:05)

Since drama school we did

Joe Mantello (03:07)

the Los Angeles production of Angels in America. He played Belize and I played Lewis before we came here. And then after that, he went into a play that also went to Broadway called The Song of Jacob Zulu. And I came to New York with Angels. So we go back we go back that far. And the beauty of with friends throughout the years, I'm sure, is wonderful. I have so many questions too about you.

Mikayla (03:07)

Los Angeles production of Angels in America. He played Belise and I played Lewis before we came here. And then after that, he went into a play that also went to Broadway called The Song of Jacob Zulu. And I came to New York with Angels. Wow. So we go back, we go back that far. And the beauty of collaborations with friends throughout the years, I'm sure, is wonderful. I have so many questions too about you

not grappling, but striking a balance between your life as a creative with so many.

Joe Mantello (03:30)

Not grappling, but between your life as a creative with so many productions

Mikayla (03:35)

Productions you've done as a director and as an actor, but let's start with how do you take care of yourself? Because you've had quite a year.

Joe Mantello (03:36)

you've done as a director and as an actor. But let's start with how do you take care of yourself? Because you've had quite

a year. Yeah. well I don't I don't I I live in New York when necessary. Okay. So that is a big part of it. I live out west, in the desert most of the time. I would consider that my home.

Mikayla (03:49)

Necessary. Okay. So that is a big part of it. I live out west, in the desert most of the time. I would consider that my home.

Joe Mantello (03:59)

but I do have a place here and I come to New York when I fortunate

Mikayla (03:59)

but I do have a place here and I come to New York when I'm fortunate.

Joe Mantello (04:03)

enough to work and so the time away I think is really it's been so essential over the last few years and I think I found a nice balance between the two. So that's really that. I first moved to Palm Springs and now I live in Rancho Mirage.

Mikayla (04:04)

So the time away I think is really it's been so essential over the last few years and I think I found a nice balance between the two. So how long have you lived out west? Probably since two thousand fourteen. I first moved to Palm Springs and now I live in Rancho Mirage. What's your

favorite thing about that? About that? Yes. Rancho Mira well, Palm Springs I I just I I fell in love with years ago.

Joe Mantello (04:24)

About that? Rancho Mora well, Palm Springs I I just I fell in love with years ago

after I directed Other

Desert Cities and I went out there for a research trip. but then it got kind of crazy during and after the pandemic. It became, you know, Palm Springs goes in and out of favor and it's very much in favor right now. And so it got kind

Mikayla (04:32)

cities and I went out there for a research trip. but then it got kind of crazy during and after the pandemic. It became, you know, Palm Springs goes in and out of favor and it's very much in favor right now. And so it got kind

Joe Mantello (04:44)

of more populated than when I first lived there. Rancho Mirage, on the other hand,

Mikayla (04:47)

Rancho Moraz on the other

Joe Mantello (04:48)

doesn't have downtown

Or you know, and so there's no it's just kind of quiet. There. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Quiet. Yeah, yeah. Quiet is beautiful. But being able to have that home base where it's just Yeah, yeah, yeah. It's great. It's really nice. That is beautiful. Yeah. So when you I'm going back to Down State Lemon, I'm gonna do like a little zip zap zop to this absolutely interview. Yeah, yeah, yeah. what was your first emotional reaction when you read Down State?

Mikayla (04:51)

And so there's no, it's just kind of quiet. Fair. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Quiet. Quiet is beautiful. But then being able to have that home base where it's just able to decompress, I'm sure, is wonderful. It's really nice. That is beautiful. So when you I'm going back to Downstate, and then I'm gonna I'm gonna do like a little zip-zap zop of this interview and we'll piece it all together. what was your first emotional reaction when

you read Downstate? You know, like all of Bruce's plays, they're so

Joe Mantello (05:15)

You know, like all of Bruce's plays, they're so

provocative and they're thorny and he

Mikayla (05:19)

Mm-hmm.

Joe Mantello (05:22)

he he he sort of pushes you into parts of yourself that are really uncomfortable. And and he's okay with it. I think he just sort of lets you sit with it. And one of the things that I keep hearing, even I think we're six previews in, six or seven previews in.

Mikayla (05:22)

He he he sort of pushes you into parts of yourself that are really uncomfortable. Yeah. And and he's okay with it. I think he just sort of lets you sit with it. And one of the things that I keep hearing, even I think we're six previews in, six or seven previews in,

that people feel compelled after they leave the theater to, you know, go into the night or go to a restaurant, go to a bar and talk about it for a really long time. And

Joe Mantello (05:36)

that people feel compelled after they leave the theater to, you know, go into the night or go to a restaurant or go to a bar and talk about it for a really long time. And

I think you know, when's the last time a play did that? and I think his plays sort of demand that. They're not easy. And yet, strangely enough they're for as dark as the the subject matter is.

Mikayla (05:49)

You when's the last time play did that? and I think his plays sort of demand that they're not easy, and yet, strangely enough, they're for as dark as the the subject matter is,

there's so much humor in it. And I think that's part of the uneasiness, is that it is actually in places very entertaining, and it depends on, and so he asks you to.

Joe Mantello (06:00)

There's so much humor in it. And I think that's part of the uneasiness, is that it is actually in places very entertaining and it depends on and so he asks you to

question yourself about

Mikayla (06:11)

Question yourself about

Joe Mantello (06:13)

What is redeemable, right? At what point has someone

Mikayla (06:13)

What is redeemable, right? Yeah. At what point has someone

Joe Mantello (06:17)

done the penance for what they've done? And people feel differently about it. Some people feel that in this particular case, these men, aren't irredeemable. And some people think, well, you know, they've done their time and

Mikayla (06:17)

Done the penance for what they've done. And people feel differently about it. Some people feel that in this particular case, these men are irredeemable. And some people think, well, you know, they've done their time and

Joe Mantello (06:31)

You know, what what else should be asked of them? Right. It's interesting that I it reminds me of Ibsen in some ways, I think as performers we always want to walk that line of showing the humanity in everyone. And I I presume as an actor you would have to go into the production trying to find the justification

Mikayla (06:31)

you what what else should be asked of them. Right. It's interesting that I it reminds me of Ibsen in some ways, I think as performers, we always want to walk that line of showing the humanity in everyone. And I I presume as an actor, you would have to go into the production trying to find the justification

Joe Mantello (06:53)

of why you've arrived in the position.

Mikayla (06:53)

Of why you've arrived in the position

you've arrived as your character. And so that would shine through to the audience and in the writing, but then you realize they've done these varying horrific things. Yeah. And I'm told,

Joe Mantello (06:55)

your character. And so that would shine through to the audience and rewriting, but then you realize they've done these very horrific things. Horrific things, yeah.

Mikayla (07:06)

well okay, I don't want to go too far into the pot, but so as a director, how do you invite the audience to empathize with this character without suggesting that empathy is the same thing as absolution?

Joe Mantello (07:08)

Yeah, yeah, yeah. So as a director, how do character without suggesting that empathy is the same thing as absolution?

Mm-hmm. I mean, I wouldn't frame it in that way because my job uh our job, th th you know,

Mikayla (07:22)

Mm-hmm.

Joe Mantello (07:23)

work the people who are working on this, our job is not to provide empathy, our job is to or

Mikayla (07:25)

Our job is not to provide empathy, our job is to

Joe Mantello (07:31)

find a way to tell this story as truthfully as possible, as humanly as possible. And the questions that exist in the gray areas

Mikayla (07:31)

find a way to tell this story as truthfully as possible, as humanly as possible. And the questions that exist in the gray areas

Joe Mantello (07:41)

aren't for us to solve or Fair. Has working on downstage challenged any of your own assumptions?

Mikayla (07:41)

Aren't for us to solve or sort out. Fair. Fair. Has working on Downstate challenged any of your own assumptions

around accountability or empathy or what theater should ask of an audience? Well, I mean I sort of like it.

Joe Mantello (07:53)

Well, I I mean I sort of like it

that it really asks questions as opposed to sort of tells you things that you already know. The challenge of it is I think is the exciting part of it. That there are no easy answers and there are no correct answers in this play. Yeah.

Mikayla (07:56)

asks questions as opposed to sort of tells you things that you already know. The challenge of it is I think is the exciting part of it. That there are no easy answers and there are no correct answers in this play. Right.

Absolutely.

it sounds like from what you've said already, Broadway audiences are still willing to be uncomfortable,

Joe Mantello (08:11)

It sounds like from what you've said already, Broadway audiences are still willing to be uncomfortable.

do we think that's true based on what you've seen on previews that we're willing to have these post show conversations and go out to

Mikayla (08:16)

Do we think that's true based on what you've seen on previews that we're willing to have these post show conversations and go out to

the bar and talk about it, based off what you've seen in audience reactions leaving the theater?

Joe Mantello (08:26)

Yeah, it seemed

like you know, I was watching it last night, I was watching the preview last night, and again it's still

Mikayla (08:30)

Still.

Joe Mantello (08:31)

early days, but there was a kind of stillness in the audience in Act Two that

Mikayla (08:32)

was a kind of stillness in the audience in Act Two that

it was just sort of thrilling because of the play, because of the work that the actors were doing, you could tell people, it seemed like people were most people were really gripped by it and kind of having to wrestle with it. Particularly if you know nothing about the play and where it goes in the second sure.

Joe Mantello (08:37)

it was just sort of thrilling because of the play, because of the work that the actors were doing, you could tell people, it seemed like people were most people were really gripped by it and kind of having to wrestle with it. Particular if you know nothing about the play and where it goes in the second act.

so

Mikayla (08:54)

So

Joe Mantello (08:55)

I'm I'm I'm I'm encouraged that that people seem to be really tuned into it.

Mikayla (08:57)

that that people seem to be really tuned into it.

Yeah. Something I really appreciate from a marketing perspective is that in order to see smallmouth sounds you have to see downstate. What prompted that choice?

Joe Mantello (09:01)

Something I really appreciate from a marketing perspective is that in order see

downstate. What prompted that choice? I don't know. I actually don't know. I don't know. I mean,

Mikayla (09:12)

I loved it.

Joe Mantello (09:14)

you know, I mean I think it's interesting because, you know, you hear things, right? You hear noise around certain projects and you hear people saying

Mikayla (09:15)

It's interesting because you know you hear things right? You hear noise around certain projects and you hear people saying that

Joe Mantello (09:24)

That smallmouth sounds is just a collection of celebrities who are slumming on Broadway. And well, but I think that's true. I mean, you hear you hear that, right? And you think like, well, when I go through that cast, I think almost

Mikayla (09:24)

smallmouth sounds is just a collection of celebrities who are slumming on Broadway. and well but I think that's true. I mean you hear you hear that, right? True, yeah.

Joe Mantello (09:37)

all of them have had some sort of career in the theater. And so there's this kind of generalization because because they're celebrities, because they're well known,

Mikayla (09:38)

some sort of career in the theater. Yes. And so there's this kind of generalization because because they're celebrities, because they're well known.

Joe Mantello (09:48)

that somehow.

Mikayla (09:49)

somehow

that they're wanting to do this play isn't

Joe Mantello (09:50)

that they're wanting to do this play isn't

Mikayla (09:53)

Isn't legitimate in some way. You know? Yeah. And so I think what I like about it, and I don't really know the thought behind it, is like, okay, if that's your beef, right? You don't want celebrities on Broadway. Yeah. Here's another play with some of the best actors working in New York today. Yes. Right? Absolutely. If that's your thing, if you for whatever reason you're allergic to the kind of celebrity culture on Broadway and paying whatever those tickets cost.

Joe Mantello (09:53)

Isn't legitimate in some way, you know? And so I think what I like about it, and I don't really know the thought behind it, is like, okay, if that's your beef, right? You you don't want celebrities on Broadway. Yeah. Here's another play with some of the best actors working in New York today. Right? So if that's your thing, if you for whatever reason you're allergic to the kind of celebrity culture on Broadway and paying whatever those tickets cost.

Here's an a here's an opportunity to see it. And so the fact that they're linked in some way to

Mikayla (10:20)

Here's an here's an opportunity to see it. And so the fact that they're linked in some way to

Joe Mantello (10:26)

provide an entry point to smallmouth sounds that is more affordable, and also to get people to see a

Mikayla (10:26)

An entry point to small mouth sounds that is more affordable, and also to get people to see

a new play that is some kind of tricky subject matter. I don't know. I think this the synchronicity of those two things working in conjunction with one another.

Joe Mantello (10:34)

a new play that is some kind of tricky subject matter. I don't know. I think this the synchronicity of those two things working in conjunction with one another

is an interesting marketing tool. Yeah I think it's brilliant, especially in the current climate of Broadway with how we're trying to keep shows afloat in the economy, celebrity quote unquote.

Mikayla (10:42)

is interesting marketing tool. Yeah, I think it's brilliant, especially in the current climate of Broadway, with how we're trying to keep shows afloat in the economy, celebrity quote unquote

stunt casting. I think every celebrity on Broadway is immensely talented, but just trying to figure out how to keep shows buoyant during this time has been pretty difficult. And so to invite people to see celebrities who are theater actors first or you know.

Joe Mantello (10:52)

On casting, I think every celebrity on Broadway is immensely talented, but just trying to figure out how to keep shows buoyant during this time has been pretty difficult. And so to invite people to see celebrities who are theater actors first, or you know,

Mikayla (11:09)

have that training. Yeah. At some point in their training, of course. And I feel like

Joe Mantello (11:09)

at some point in their career, yeah. I feel like every

Mikayla (11:12)

every not every, because that's an absolute, but just to say that every performer is out here being creative, whether you're celebrity or boots on the ground in the off-Broadway scene, because we care

Joe Mantello (11:22)

Because we can

Mikayla (11:23)

about what we do and because we want to bring these stories to life. And so

Joe Mantello (11:25)

And so

Mikayla (11:26)

knowing that that love and that drive is there, but we're seeing both sides of the same coin. We're the folks that have like succeeded in the conventional definition of success.

Joe Mantello (11:29)

Seeing both sides of the same coin where the folks that have like succeeded in the conventional definition of success

are on this stage, but so are people that you may have never heard of unless you are already in this scene talking about some profoundly difficult topics that I think are really important to discuss, especially when it comes to moral ambiguity. And I'm I'm just gonna keep going back to that term because I didn't spoil the plot, but yeah, I think it's really necessary.

Mikayla (11:36)

are on this stage, but so are people that you may have never heard of unless you are already in this scene talking about some profoundly difficult topics that I think are really important to discuss, especially when it comes to moral ambiguity. And I'm I'm just gonna keep going back to that term because I don't want to spoil the plot. But yeah, I think it's really necessary.

And I think it's a great way to bring two different shows to life on Broadway at hopefully similar times. I'm

Joe Mantello (11:59)

I think it's great way to bring two different shows to life on Broadway at hopefully similar times. I'm

presume they'll both be running around the same time. I think so, yeah. I think it's brilliant. I think it's really good. Is there any particular question that you would love audiences to continue debating?

Mikayla (12:05)

presume they'll both be running around the same time. But I yeah. I just I think it's brilliant. I think it's really good. Is there any particular question that you would love audiences to continue debating on

the way home?

Joe Mantello (12:17)

I this play is so complicated that to kind of synthesize it down to a single question is nearly impossible. I mean and that's the gr that's the great thing about all of Bruce's plays, you know. He's he's got this uncanny knack for pushing buttons while also being credibly entertaining.

Mikayla (12:21)

synthesize it down to a single question is nearly impossible. I mean that's the that's the great thing about all of Bruce's plays. You know, he's he's got this uncanny knack for pushing buttons while also entertaining.

I love walking out of a show and just spending hours talking about

Joe Mantello (12:37)

I love walking out of a show and just spending hours talking about

Mikayla (12:40)

how I feel about it or how other people feel. And

How two people can go into the same show or the same experience and leave with vastly different opinions based off of their own lived experience. And I think that that is really valuable. I've had experiences where, you know, and I hope if someone comes to this production of Bruce's play and leaves and they're angry and they

Joe Mantello (12:44)

Same show or the same experience and leave with vastly different opinions based off of their own lived had experiences where, you know, and I hope if someone comes to this production of Bruce's play and leaves and they're angry and they

are

upset by what they've seen, but they continue to think about it during their week or the weeks afterwards, if it stays with them. I think there is something in that. I mean I've certainly had experiences where I've gone to see I think I can think of w in one case this this film,

Mikayla (13:03)

Upset by what they've seen, but they continue to think about it during their week or the weeks afterwards, if it stays with them. I think there is something in that. I mean, I've certainly had experiences where I've gone to see I think I can think of in one case, this this film

Joe Mantello (13:20)

Well, I when I saw Brokeback Mountain, I ha I know. Okay. So so I saw it and I s went to the theater and I saw it and I left and I was so angry and I just hated everything about it, right? I just it did not move me. I didn't get it on any level. and then I read the novella.

Mikayla (13:20)

Well, I when I saw Broke Back Mountain, I ha I know. So I saw it and I went to the theater and I saw it and I left and I was so angry and I just hated everything about it. Right. I just it did not move me. I didn't get it on any level. and then I read the novella

because I kept thinking about it. So I read the novella and I went

Joe Mantello (13:39)

'Cause I kept thinking about it. So I read the novella and I went

back to see it and I've seen it several times. It is one of my favorite movies now. So I've learned to, personally, I've learned to approach something with a certain amount of humility to say, in this particular case of Brokeback Mountain,

Mikayla (13:42)

To see it and I've seen it several times. It is one of my favorite movies. So I've learned to personally I've learned to approach something with a certain amount of humility to say, in this particular case of Broken Mountain,

maybe it was what I was feeling that day, or maybe it was able to seep into my unconscious in a way that it worked on me in a way that I was not expecting. Right. In that particular case, I there's that's something that where I

Joe Mantello (13:55)

Maybe it was what I was feeling that day, or maybe it it was able to seep into my unconscious in a way that it worked on me in a way that I was not expecting. So in that particular case, I there's that's something that where I

went from really being repelled by it to it being in, you know, top ten films. What aspect repelled you and how did that kind of flip on its head?

Mikayla (14:13)

What aspect repelled you and how did that kind of flip on its head? Do you

even remember? Were you just like

Joe Mantello (14:17)

I just remember thinking it was

I don't I don't remember, but I remember I remember I went to see it with a Idina Menzel of all people, because it was around that time.

Mikayla (14:24)

Incredible.

Joe Mantello (14:25)

And I remember leaving and we saw it at the Grove in Los Angeles

Mikayla (14:30)

Yeah.

Joe Mantello (14:30)

and I just didn't like it. And repelled is too strong a word. I just didn't like it. I just didn't understand what the fuss of it about it was. But when I look back on that film and again I've seen it so many times, I mean those performances

Mikayla (14:32)

And rappelled is too strong a word. I just didn't like it. I just didn't understand what the fuss of it was. But when I look back on that film and again I've seen it so many times, I mean those performances

and the screenplay and the direction are peerless.

Joe Mantello (14:43)

And the screenplay and the direction are peerless.

No absolutely. I think it's fascinating too, but just what a fun thought experiment of you can enter an experience and based off of your day, it can be the silliest thing, but it's just like this is not diving with my energy of the day, or you are strong

Mikayla (14:47)

Absolutely. I think it's fascinating too, for just what a fun thought experiment of you can enter an experience and based off of your day, it could be the silliest thing, but it's just like this is not jiving with my energy of the day. Or you are strongly

feeling something disgust, excitement, et cetera, because of your ideology and how you feel about it. Right. So it's like I might subconsciously just

Joe Mantello (15:03)

Feeling something disgust, excitement, etc., because of your ideology and how you feel about it, right? So it's like I might subconsciously just

be having a reaction to this based off of my own life, and I'm not even processing that until after I leave the theater or the cinema or after I sit with that book for a while. And then when you return to it, you're actually, this tells me some things about myself that I didn't know before. And actually, I really like going to the core feeling underneath my.

Mikayla (15:12)

be having a reaction to this based off of my own life. And I'm not even processing that until after I leave the theater or the cinema or after I sit with that book for a while. And then when you return to it, you're like, actually this tells me some things about myself that I didn't know before. And actually I really like going to the core feeling underneath why

I'm having this visceral reaction.

Joe Mantello (15:31)

visceral reaction

Mikayla (15:33)

is so telling and I feel like you grow so much as a person from it, even if it's broke back mountain. But in this case, you know, it could have just been the energy of the day. Like this just isn't sitting with the type of things that I want to consume. I've only seen things that I haven't responded to and my opinion has not changed. but in this particular case it

Joe Mantello (15:33)

is so telling and feel like you grow so as a person it. Even if it's Brookback Mountain. But you know, it could have just been the energy of the day. Like this just isn't the type of things that I want to Yeah. Yeah. I mean that's certainly seen things that I haven't responded to and my opinion has not changed. it but in this particular case it

Mikayla (15:53)

I guess what I'm saying is there was there was something that was lingering in my unconscious about this movie that I couldn't let go of. I mean what was the thing that propelled me to go read the novella? Because I couldn't I couldn't it just kept coming back in my

Joe Mantello (15:53)

guess what I'm saying is there was there was something that was lingering in my unconscious about this movie that I couldn't let go of. I mean, what was the thing that propelled me to go read the novella? Because I couldn't I couldn't it just kept coming back in my

brain and I thought like I have to I want to know more about this. Did the source material fundamentally change the way you saw it? Or were you like, I want to go and see the movie again, what I know from the source material?

Mikayla (16:12)

Did the source material fundamentally change the way you saw it? Or were you like, I wanna go and see the movie again, knowing what I know from the source material?

Joe Mantello (16:20)

Yes, I think it was that. It was that the source material made me want to see

Mikayla (16:20)

Yes, I think it was that. It was that the source material made me want to see

Joe Mantello (16:23)

it again and I think I was in a different place when I saw it again and having I don't know what I don't know what it was. And

Mikayla (16:30)

And

Joe Mantello (16:31)

anyway, so I I hope that people even if people have a very strong reaction they have an allergic reaction to the characters and the situations of this of this

Mikayla (16:31)

Anyway, so I I think that people, even if people have a very strong reaction they have an allergic reaction to the characters and the situations of this of this

deeply thorny play that they sort of sit with it for a while and see what comes up. Maybe nothing, maybe something really profound. Sure, I think it's worth discussing, certainly. I do you think that this is a very open ended question? Do you think redemption is possible?

Joe Mantello (16:40)

deeply thorny play that they sort of sit with it for a while and see what comes up. Maybe nothing, maybe something really profound. Sure, but think it's worth discussing certainly. Do you think that this is a very open-ended question? Do you think redemption is possible

Mikayla (16:59)

Possible and do you think society should offer it regarding this particular subject matter?

Joe Mantello (16:59)

and do you think society should offer it in regarding to subject matter?

Mikayla (17:06)

I think I have to believe that redemption is possible, right? Yeah. You know, and

Joe Mantello (17:06)

I think I have to believe that redemption is possible, right? I have to believe that that people are capable of evolving if they choose to, right? You know,

You know, look at Barack Obama's evolving stance over gay marriage, right? Over the course of his presidency. Now, if I wrote him off as a homophobe at the beginning of his presidency, but he evolved, you know, and I think that we're at a time in in the theater in what we do right now where we're being asked to become

Mikayla (17:18)

You know, look at Barack Obama's evolving stance over gay marriage over the course of his presidency. Now, if I wrote him off as a homophobe at the beginning of his presidency, but he evolved. Right. You know, and I think that we're in a time in in theater what we do right now, where we're being asked to become

Joe Mantello (17:39)

more sensitive, more aware to be more conscious in the workplace, right? And so we I don't know if this is true of you, but you know, we have these seminars and we have So if people aren't capable of evolving, then why would we even go through any of this? Sure, what is the point of it? Not to get existential, but why why are if not to learn and to

Mikayla (17:39)

sensitive, more aware to be more conscious in the workplace, right? Yeah. So we I don't know if this is true of you, but you know, we have these seminars and we have so if people aren't capable of evolving, then why would we even go through any of this? Sure, what is the point of life not to get existential? But why why are we here if not to learn and

to grow? And not everybody takes that off

Joe Mantello (18:04)

Yeah. And not everybody takes that opportunity.

Sure. but I have to I have to believe in the abstract that it is possible. Yeah, and I find it fascinating too, again not trying to spoil the plot, but like the relationship between Andy and Fred is so complicated because he is coming looking for this acknowledgement and this closure and then Fred challenges some of that recollection, but

Mikayla (18:06)

Sure. but I have to I have to believe in the abstract that it is possible. Yeah, and I find it fascinating too, again, not trying to spoil plot, but like the relationship between Andy and Fred is so complicated because he is coming looking for this acknowledgement and this closure, and then Fred challenges some of that recollection, but

Joe Mantello (18:23)

it's interesting that the victim is holding all of this anger

Mikayla (18:23)

it's interesting that the victim is holding all of this anger

and coming to try to find some closure from that. But then the optics of their perpetrator, who now looks a little bit more mild

Joe Mantello (18:26)

To try to find some closure from that, but then the optics of the perpetrator who now looks a little bit more mild.

Mikayla (18:34)

and sympathetic, it kind of flips on the head

Joe Mantello (18:34)

Sympathetic, it kind of flips on the head

Mikayla (18:36)

it's so fascinating to see how these Thorny is the perfect word for it, but just to see how anger and trauma can really affect

Joe Mantello (18:36)

it's so fascinating to see how these riethorny is the perfect word for it, but just to see how anger and trauma can really affect.

Mikayla (18:45)

who somebody becomes and just to say like what.

Joe Mantello (18:45)

who somebody becomes and just to say like what

this does to a person, how it tears you apart

Mikayla (18:48)

this does to a person, how it tears you apart,

how do you approach that conversation without like steering the audience toward one version of the truth? Because all all of these things are true. Everyone is partly right. Yeah. I mean you

Joe Mantello (18:51)

how do you approach that conversation without like steering the audience toward one version of the truth? Because all all of these things are true. Everyone is partly right. Yeah, I mean you

you I think you do it moment by moment, and you think you ask yourself, or you know, you and the actor ask yourselves, okay, so what is

Mikayla (19:07)

So what is

Joe Mantello (19:08)

Andy here to do? I think Andy enters the play and he has a plan which he thinks will bring him closure.

Mikayla (19:12)

plan which he thinks will bring him closure. And

Joe Mantello (19:15)

And he has been in a survivors group. And so he comes armed with the jargon and the therapy that one gets in that. And I think believes that once he reaches the end of this ritual with his abuser, that he will be able to like leave it behind. Right.

Mikayla (19:15)

he has been in a survivors group, and so he comes armed with the jargon and the therapy that one gets in that. And I think believes that once he reaches the end of this ritual with his abuser, that he will be able to like leave it behind. Right.

Joe Mantello (19:34)

And through a series of events in the first scene, it doesn't go quite the way in which he expects it to go.

Mikayla (19:34)

And through a series of events in the first scene, it doesn't go quite the way in which he expects it to go. Right.

And it is, in fact, interrupted before he is able to find that kind of closure, right? So something happens in the second act, and he's appealing we see him in the second act. And I think he gets closer to what it is that he wants. He gets closer to

Joe Mantello (19:41)

And it is in fact interrupted before he is able to find that kind of closure, right? So something happens in the second act, and he's he we see him in the second act, and I think he gets closer to what it is that he wants. He gets closer to

because Fred, his abuser, is

Mikayla (20:00)

Because Fred, his abuser, is

saying everything that you want him to say. He's saying he's apologizing, he's taking responsibility for it. But I think what Andy ultimately feels is that the understanding of the profound impact that this has had on his life.

Joe Mantello (20:04)

Saying everything that you want him to say. He's saying that he's apologizing, he's taking responsibility for it. But I think what Andy ultimately feels is that the the understanding of the profound impact that this has had on his life,

Mikayla (20:25)

that there's no emotional acknowledgement. There's a kind of an intellectual acknowledgement. And I think what Andy's looking for, perhaps, I don't know. I have I I keep I keep struggling with this is I think what he's saying is what he walks away with is this is never going away. Right. And how do

Joe Mantello (20:25)

That there's no im emotional acknowledgement. There's a kind of an intellectual acknowledgement. And I think what Andy's looking for, perhaps, I don't know. I have I I keep I keep struggling with this, is I think what he's saying is what he walks away with is this is never going away. Right.

Mikayla (20:44)

you grapple with not getting the closure that you think you need? Or you put

Joe Mantello (20:47)

think you need or you put

you quantify the closure. If I get this, then I will experience closure. when that doesn't when it doesn't come. Or it doesn't come over the course of the play, and

Mikayla (20:49)

you quantify the closure. If I get this, then I will experience closure. What happens when that doesn't happen? And it will never be enough.

Joe Mantello (20:58)

it will never be enough. But I think I think he he has all of the right jargon in the first act that he's armed with that and he thinks that that's gonna

Mikayla (20:59)

think he he has all of the right jargon in the first act that he's armed with that and he thinks that that's gonna

Joe Mantello (21:08)

provide it. And in fact I think he gets to a much

deeper place in himself about where this pain exists and has been living and will maybe go on for the rest of his life. Certainly. Yeah. Drawing on the theme, crazy parallel to make, ride with me here. have you ever experienced a situation in which you have not received closure and how do you live with that? That does not have to be nearly as deep or thorny as the subject matter here, but just the the feeling.

Mikayla (21:11)

Deeper place in himself about where pain exists and has been living and will maybe go on for the rest of his life. Certainly. drawing on the theme, crazy parallel to make, but ride with me here. have you ever experienced a situation which you have not received closure? And how do you live with that? That does not have to be nearly as deep or thorny as the subject matter here, but just the the feeling. Yeah.

Joe Mantello (21:36)

Yeah, I mean I do.

Mikayla (21:36)

I mean I do.

Joe Mantello (21:37)

I mean I guess it's just like what are the things that give you closure? For me, I'm not afraid of I'm not afraid of conflict and I'm not afraid of confrontation and I like I'm not frightened of honest conversations, but not everybody in the world is comfortable with that. And so sometimes when I find that I'm

Mikayla (21:50)

Everybody in the world is comfortable with that. Sure. And so sometimes when I find that I'm

Joe Mantello (21:54)

looking for closure or answers

Mikayla (21:55)

closure or answers

Joe Mantello (21:57)

in conjunction with another person that it might not come and so I'm I'm still learning to kind of like let that go and to say like you know ultimately only I can give myself the closure that I need. Cheers. Yeah and I think that's the most important thing you can draw upon in this life. I remember my grandfather told me once he was like you can trust no one in this life but yourself. You can hold

Mikayla (21:57)

in conjunction with another person that it might not come. And so I'm I'm still learning to kind of like let that go and to say like, you know, ultimately only I can give myself the closure that I need. Cheers. Yeah. I I think that's the most important thing you can draw upon in this life. I remember my grandfather told me once he was like, you can trust no one in this life but yourself. You can hold

Joe Mantello (22:19)

you nobody fully accountable in your

life.

Mikayla (22:19)

nobody fully accountable in your life

except yourself. You can try all you want to and you can hope and wish, but you have to you are the only person you have control over. So I mean that's a horrible thing to say in the face of like so much trauma, but at the end of the day that will eat you alive or you just have

Joe Mantello (22:22)

accept yourself. You can try. You can try, yeah. But you have to you are the only person you have control over. So I mean that's a horrible thing to say in the face of like so much trauma, but at the end of the day that will eat you alive or you just

Mikayla (22:37)

to find the tools to stay buoyant. Have to, I mean, it's it's all tricky language to describe like the the palpable deep feelings that trauma can evoke or

Joe Mantello (22:39)

Yep, exactly. I mean it's it's all tricky language to describe like the the palpable deep feelings that trauma can evoke or

any sort of conflict, but just to say that yeah, you sometimes you really are not gonna get the catharsis that you're not gonna get it. No how do you

Mikayla (22:47)

any sort of conflict but just to say that yeah, you sometimes you really are not gonna get the catharsis that you're looking for in the world and how do you

live with that? You know, I yeah.

Joe Mantello (22:58)

Some people are

good about well, I don't I don't wanna say I make a value judgment about it. Some people are more comfortable with unresolved issues. I am not but I'm learning, I'm trying to learn that.

Mikayla (23:04)

Resolved issues. Yeah. I am not. But I'm learning. I'm trying to learn that.

it's just fascinating to watch people be eaten alive by things that have happened to them that should never have happened. And yet, how do you continue living in the world? How do you continue being the best version of yourself and not letting that define

Joe Mantello (23:11)

it's just fascinating to watch people be eaten alive by things that have happened to them that should never have happened. Yeah. And yet, how do you continue living in the world? How do you continue being the best version of yourself and not letting that define

Mikayla (23:25)

fundamentally who you are? I think that's what's successful about what Bruce

is.

Joe Mantello (23:26)

I think that's what's successful about what Bruce has

done because as you said, Fred, who is Andy's abuser, is you're meeting him at a point in his life where he's incredibly vulnerable. he he was beaten in prison, his spine was broken, he's in a wheelchair, he's he's he's

Mikayla (23:28)

Because as you said, Fred, who is Andy's abuser, is you're meeting him at a point in his life where he's incredibly vulnerable. he he was beaten in prison, his spine was broken, he's in a wheelchair, he's he's he's

he's a different person. He speaks in a very childlike way. There's a sweetness about him.

Joe Mantello (23:45)

He's a different person. He speaks in a very childlike way. There's a sweetness about him.

And so your I think your empathy is aligned with that, you know. And then there's a moment in the second act where Andy actually articulates not only what he what

Mikayla (23:53)

And so your I think your empathy is aligned with that, you know? Yeah. And then there's a moment in the second act where Andy actually articulates not only what what

Cr Fred did, the crime, but the impact of it. And so then you're left with you're holding both of these parallel narratives at the same time. Right. And you have to exist where you are.

Joe Mantello (24:07)

cr Fred did the crime, but the impact of it. And so then you're left with you're holding both of these parallel narratives at the same time. And you have to exist where you are

on the scale, you know? Yes. And as you said earlier, the the reinvention of the people as we grow, you would meet people as they are

Mikayla (24:20)

On the scale. Yes. And as you said earlier, the the reinvention of of people as we grow, you would meet people as they are in

whatever stage of their life and see the optics of who they are and what they present and who they are today may not reflect the entire scope of the life and the

Joe Mantello (24:29)

stage of their life and see the optics of who they are and what they present and who they are today may not reflect the entire scope of the life and the

Mikayla (24:37)

the perception, I know Ross, my partner, was saying he loved that he just comes out of the chair and you're like, what a sweet man. Like you have so much sympathy for him, and then you find out what he did, and you're like, that's almost unfathomable that this

Joe Mantello (24:37)

the perception, I know Ross, my partner, was saying he loved that he just comes out in the chair, and you're like, what a sweet man. Like you have so much sympathy for him, and then you find out what he did. What he did. And that's almost unfathomable that this

person would be capable of something.

Mikayla (24:50)

person could be capable of something

like that.

And it was thirty, you know, thirty plus years ago. Yeah. And, you know, he's clearly, i in dire straits. I mean, he's living in a halfway house with three other roommates and he's in a wheelchair and so

Joe Mantello (24:53)

And it was thirty, you know, thirty plus years ago and you know, he's clearly, i in dire straits. I mean, he's living in a halfway house with three other roommates and he's in a wheelchair and so

his vulnerabilities are challenging when measured against

Mikayla (25:08)

his vulnerabilities are challenging when measured against,

you know, his crime. Mm-hmm.

Joe Mantello (25:14)

You know, w his crime.

Mikayla (25:16)

I wanna talk about you a little bit. Okay. Okay. First we're gonna go for like silly little inner child kind of conversation. when you think about the younger version of yourself, do you think that he would imagine your life like this? Is this is would you recognize the life you had

Joe Mantello (25:18)

Okay. Okay. First we're gonna go for like silly little you know child kind of conversation. When you think about the younger version of yourself, do you think that he would imagine your life like this? Is this is would you recognize the life you had?

Mikayla (25:31)

now?

That was kinda framed weird, but you know what I'm saying? Like I I think the answer is yes and no. Okay. That I always knew I grew up in Rockford, Illinois, and I always knew that

Joe Mantello (25:31)

kind of frame. Yeah, no, I understand. I under yeah, I understand. I I think the answer is yes and no. That I always knew I grew up in Rockford, Illinois, and I always knew that

my life would not be there. And so I knew that

Mikayla (25:46)

be there. Yeah. And so I knew that

I knew that I wanted that I had ambition and that I wanted to I didn't know what exactly I didn't know what it looked like, but I knew that I would I don't want to say get out. but I knew that I would go on to do other things. Right. Well you're

Joe Mantello (25:50)

I knew that I wanted that I had ambition and that I wanted to I didn't know what exactly I didn't know what it looked like, but I knew that I would I don't want to say get out, but I knew that I would go on to do other things. Right.

Mikayla (26:04)

limited by your environment, even if you love it. Yeah, yeah.

Joe Mantello (26:06)

Yeah, yeah.

the makeup of my life now, the the realities of my life now, I could never imagine. I would never have imagined as a kid that I would be a director. It wasn't even something that I you know, I mean certainly I did community theater and there a director, but it didn't occur to me that that was something that I would end up doing. Was there somebody that saw something see in yourself that prompted that?

Mikayla (26:13)

kid that I would be a director. It wasn't even something that I, you know, I mean, certainly I did community theater and there a director, but didn't occur to me that that was something that I would end up doing. Was there somebody that saw something in you that you didn't see in yourself that prompted that

or how did you arrive at directing? when I moved to the city in the mid eighties, I was a member of the Circle Repertory

Company.

Joe Mantello (26:30)

Yeah. when I moved to the city in the mid eighties, I was a member of the Circle Repertory Company.

and they had a sort of a second company, a lab space, and you could do these they would just you would

Mikayla (26:37)

And they had a sort of a second company, a lab space, and you could do these they would just you would

it was a tiny little black box theater of 99 seats and I was an actor at the time, but I wanted to I just wanted to try my hand at directing and so you sort of applied for a slot and you were given I think a hundred dollars or a hundred fifty dollars to produce it and add some lights and and I

Joe Mantello (26:44)

was a tiny little black box theater of ninety nine seats and I was an actor at the time, but I wanted to I just wanted to try my hand at directing. And so you sort of applied for a slot and you were given, I think, a hundred dollars or $150 to produce it and they had some lights and and I d

did this play, directed this play, and people liked it and so they moved it to the main stage the following season. And it was

Mikayla (27:01)

Did this play, directed this play, and people liked it, and so they moved it to the main stage the following season. All right. And it was

Joe Mantello (27:10)

absolutely decimated by the critics. So so didn't stop you. No. Well, because the woman who

Mikayla (27:10)

absolutely decimated by the critics. No. But that didn't stop you. Well, because the woman who

Joe Mantello (27:19)

ran the company at the time, Tanya Berrison, said you have to do it again.

Mikayla (27:21)

said, you have to do it again.

You have to do it again. And maybe it was because it was the company mentality and ensemble mentality. And so I got to try it a couple more times. And and without that kind of support, I don't I don't know if it would happen today. I mean I think it I feel like these days, you know, you have something that doesn't work and

Joe Mantello (27:23)

You have to do it again. And maybe it was because it was the company mentality, an ensemble mentality. And so I got to try it a couple more times. And and without that kind of support, I'm not I don't know if it would happen today. I mean, I think it I feel like these days, you know, you have something that doesn't work and

it

it's hard to get a second chance.

Mikayla (27:44)

It's hard to get a second chance.

I it the social media age is also really hard because the digital footprint just lives forever and is it's hard to get out from under that. How do you handle criticism?

Joe Mantello (27:47)

Social media is also really hard because the digital footprint just lives forever. is it's hard to get out from under that. Yeah. How do you handle criticism?

how do I handle it? Do you have to, or do you just kind of like shut your eyes off to the No, I know a lot of people say that they

Mikayla (27:59)

how do I handle it? Do you have to or do you just kind of like shut your eyes off to the No, know a lot of people say that they

Joe Mantello (28:06)

don't they they don't

Read reviews. I read reviews. You know, look, I here's the fact of the matter is like I've been around a long time and I I've outlived or most critics, you know, that were writing when, there's you know, it's like the Sondheim lyric, I'm still here. You know, that is how I feel, you know. I mean, I've got tons of bad reviews in my wake. Tons. And probably more ahead. You know, I I I ultimately feel like at this point.

Mikayla (28:09)

know, look, here's fact of the matter is, is like I've been around a long time. Outlived, or most critics, you know, that were writing when, you there's you know, it's like the sound type lyric, I'm still here. I that is how I feel. Yeah. I've got tons of bad reviews in my wake. Tons. And probably more ahead. You know, I I I ultimately feel like at this point,

Joe Mantello (28:35)

it is not my responsibility. My responsibility is to have

Mikayla (28:35)

It is not my responsibility. My responsibility is to have

Joe Mantello (28:42)

a career that I leave behind and there will be you know hills and valleys, right? But ultimately at the end of my life, one can look back on it and say, well, this is what he did and this is what he did well, or this is the notable stuff, or

Mikayla (28:42)

a career that I leave behind and there will be you know hills and valleys. Right. But ultimately at the end of my life, one can look back on it and say, well this is what he did and this is what he did well or this is the notable stuff or

but I don't feel responsible to you know I like I think I'm like everybody I'm capable of doing shitty work. I don't intend to

Joe Mantello (28:56)

But I don't feel responsible to you know, I like I think s I'm like everybody, I'm capable of doing shitty work. I don't intend to,

but you know, it happens. But certainly you've also put in the reps

Mikayla (29:04)

But you know, it happens. But certainly you've also put in the reps

at the metaphorical gym of you are practicing this work and living through it every day. So the margin of error, I'll I'll say is lower and lower because you know how to show up

Joe Mantello (29:11)

So the margin of error I'll I'll say is lower and lower because you know how to show up.

Mikayla (29:18)

and be a consummate professional. Which

Joe Mantello (29:19)

Yeah. Well, also

you just you realize or I started to realize that ultimately I didn't have any control over how the world received the work that I was doing, right? So what did I have control over? I have control over the people that get invited into the room, the learning from the people that are invited in the room. Like those are the ways that I'm gonna get better. A good review or a bad review is

Mikayla (29:28)

received the work that I was doing, right? So what did I have control over? I have control over the people that get invited into the room, the learning from the people that are invited in the room. Like those are the ways that I'm gonna get better. good review or a bad review is

it ultimately it it doesn't it doesn't really

Joe Mantello (29:46)

It ultimately it it doesn't it doesn't really it

doesn't it doesn't really count for much, I don't think. That's fair and it yeah, that's true. If anything it it helps support the cause that people are seeing as work and conf

Mikayla (29:50)

It doesn't really count for much, I don't think. That's fair. And it yeah, that's true. If anything, it it helps support the cause that people are seeing this work and can

form an opinion about it, but that shouldn't affect your process in any way. I mean, also there are things that I've done that have gotten really, really terrible reviews that

Joe Mantello (30:01)

shouldn't affect your process any way. I mean also there are things that I've done that have gotten really, really terrible reviews.

Mikayla (30:10)

I've just loved and I wouldn't trade the experience for the world, even knowing the out.

Joe Mantello (30:10)

that I've just loved and I wouldn't trade the experience for the world, even knowing the outcome.

And there are things that I've done that have been incredibly successful that were not as satisfying creatively or personally. And, you know, a good review isn't an indicator of what I carry with me. True. Well you've also had such a enormous career commercial music.

Mikayla (30:16)

things that I've done that have been incredibly successful that were not as satisfying creatively or personally. And you know, a good review isn't an indicator of what I carry with me. True. Well you've also had such a enormous career between commercial musical

theater and like these incredibly

intimate, darker pieces. What is

Joe Mantello (30:38)

Intimate, darker pieces,

what is satisfying for you? What is the the material you think?

Mikayla (30:40)

satisfying for you? What is the common thread behind the material you're working on, do you think?

Joe Mantello (30:46)

I don't know that there is a common thread. And you know what? That's fair. I don't think so. I don't think there is. I mean, I don't think.

Mikayla (30:47)

And you know what? That's fair.

Joe Mantello (30:51)

I mean, for a long time when I was starting out, I did tons of new play, lots of new plays. but now I'm just kind of I just go where there's interesting work and interesting people.

Mikayla (30:53)

starting out I did tons of new play lots of new plays. but now I'm just kind of I just go where there's interesting work and interesting people. Yeah.

Joe Mantello (31:02)

Yeah.

Mikayla (31:02)

Had you known you were gonna work on this when you were doing Death of a Salesman?

Joe Mantello (31:06)

I don't think so. I don't think so. Yeah, I don't think so. I think it came together pretty quickly. How often do you say and how often do you say no?

Mikayla (31:07)

What a wild year for you. I don't think so. I think it came together pretty quickly. How often do you say yes and how often do you say no

for projects?

Joe Mantello (31:15)

It's hard to say. I will say that I don't at this point I don't take on anything that I don't feel confident that I can look at the writer and say, you can trust me with this. there was a time in my life when I was starting out where I took things that

Mikayla (31:15)

It's hard to say. I will say that I don't at this point I don't take on anything that I don't feel confident that I could look at the writer and say, you can trust me with this. Right. there was a time in my life when I was starting out where I took things that

Joe Mantello (31:33)

I that I maybe shouldn't have for I don't want to say the wrong reasons, but for

Mikayla (31:33)

I that I maybe shouldn't have for want to say the wrong reasons, but for

for reasons other than kind of being passionate about them.

Joe Mantello (31:38)

for reasons other than kind of being passionate about them.

Mikayla (31:42)

Sure. Yeah. Well, I I feel like it's hard to, at least from an actor perspective, the say yes attitude of the excitement of collaboration and the excitement of new work or just the ability to be in the room. You want to say yes and then you realize actually this is an expenditure of my energy that maybe I didn't have and maybe I should have

Joe Mantello (31:47)

The excitement of collaboration and the excitement of new work, or just the ability to be in the room. You want to say yes, and then you realize actually this is an expenditure of my energy that maybe I didn't have.

Mikayla (31:59)

Said no to protect my own peace. And not that there's anything bad with any aspect of it, but just to say the selectivity of your energy and what you can bring to the table is valuable. I mean it's all a hunch, right? I mean so you you either you know I've have said before that it's like when I'm reading a script, there's something there's like a like a something goes off in me and I think yes. And then something goes off in me and I think no. And it has nothing to do with the quality.

Joe Mantello (32:08)

Yeah. I mean it's all a hunch, right? I mean you don't you don't know. And so you you either th you know, I've d have said before that it's like when I'm reading a script, there's something there's like a a like a something goes off in me and I think yes. And then something goes off in me and I think no. And it has nothing to do with the quality

of it. I've I've said no to things that have gone on to be incredibly successful, but they weren't for me and they maybe wouldn't have been successful.

Mikayla (32:27)

Right. I've I've said no to things that have gone on to be incredibly successful, but they weren't for me and they maybe wouldn't have been successful

if I were at the helm. It just wasn't it didn't have the passion for it.

Joe Mantello (32:36)

if I were at the helm. It just wasn't it didn't have the passion for it.

Mikayla (32:40)

Fair. No, I think that's smart. I was talking about SNL a couple of weeks ago where sometimes the writers will come up with wonderful material, but it's like this material isn't meant.

Joe Mantello (32:48)

This material isn't meant

for so and so to say it's meant for someone else. I was I was speaking in the terms of the Shane Gillis opener, and I was like, okay, I think that the gym commentary on women, even if this joke is true, even if we are wearing the most odd outfits to the gym, the optics of this person saying this joke is fundamentally wrong.

Mikayla (32:50)

for so and so to say it's meant for someone else. I was I I was speaking in the terms of the Shane Gillis opener and I was like, okay, I think that the gym commentary on women, even if this joke is true, even if we are wearing the most odd outfits to the gym, the optics of this person saying this joke is fundamentally wrong.

but

Joe Mantello (33:12)

Now that's a terrible example of what we're discussing. But just to say that you can have brilliant people and brilliant teams and the best of intentions and you can see something and say, this is good. Maybe it is better suited for somebody else. kill your darlings of like, I see potential in this, but is this right?

Mikayla (33:12)

Now that's a terrible example in context of what we're discussing, but just to say that you can have brilliant people and brilliant teams and the best of intentions and you can see something and say, this is good, but maybe it is better suited for somebody else. kill your darlings of like, I see potential in this, but is this right

in this moment for me and for the team and in service of what we're trying to do here.

Joe Mantello (33:30)

Moment for me and for the team and in service of what we're trying to do here.

Do you feel like it ignited an interesting conversation? I do. Yeah. I do. I think it's fascinating because we try this material.

Mikayla (33:37)

Interesting conversation. I do. Yeah. I do. I think it's fascinating because he tried this material

at I think Comedy Cellar and it did not do well. And I yeah. So he did the set at, I think on a Monday, Comedy Cellar.

Joe Mantello (33:46)

is that right? I don't know much about it. So he did the set at I think on a Monday at Comedy Cell.

Mikayla (33:51)

And then for SNL, they'll do the read through, they'll select the scripts on Wednesday, then there's Thursday, Friday rehearsal. Saturday dress rehearsal with the live studio audience. And then there's like an hour to read.

Joe Mantello (33:54)

select the scripts on Wednesday, then there's Thursday, Friday rehearsal. Saturday a dress rehearsal with the live studio audience and then there's like an hour to

you know rehash material and even the cue cards people

Mikayla (34:04)

you know, rehash material. And even cue cards, y people

are editing them between eleven PM and eleven thirty before the live show. Yeah.

Joe Mantello (34:10)

really?

Mikayla (34:11)

I feel like we had to double down on saying that before it entered

Joe Mantello (34:11)

I feel like we had to double, down on saying that before it entered

the live show at eleven thirty. So that's it. So what was

Mikayla (34:17)

The live show at eleven thirty. So that's what

Joe Mantello (34:19)

the response when you did it in front of the at the the dress rehearsal?

Mikayla (34:23)

I wasn't

at that dress where it was like wish I saw it, but what the people that were there were like cringy. Yeah. I mean the band was trying not to look up, everybody was trying not to really respond. There was maybe one or two chuckles in the audience, but and and that was it. Yeah. It's amaz it's interesting that he didn't that he didn't you know, rethink it and pivot into some other material. I appreciate him in the way that he will

Joe Mantello (34:28)

Cringy. Yeah. Yeah. I mean the band was trying not to look up. Everybody was trying not to really respond. There was maybe one or two chuckles in the audience, but was it. wow. It's amaz it's interesting that he didn't that he didn't you know rethink it and pivot into you know some other material. I appreciate him in the way that he will

Mikayla (34:48)

He pushed the

Joe Mantello (34:48)

push the

Mikayla (34:49)

lines of comedy, but I also don't think we should ever punch down on our jokes. it was interesting because he was like punching down

Joe Mantello (34:51)

don't think we should ever punch down on our jokes. it was interesting because he was like punching down

Mikayla (34:56)

on women and the queer community, but then the butt of the joke was him.

And so it was almost sympathetic where it was like, but I'm making fun of me. But in the process, we've also punched down. And so I think

Joe Mantello (35:00)

So it was almost sympathetic where it was like, but I'm making fun of me, but in the process we've also punched down. So I think

comedy is really interesting in the way of like just speak to what you know. And if you have a joke that involves another demographic, like please pitch it and pass the baton to somebody else. maybe they can make better sense of that from their lived experience. there's more opportunities.

Mikayla (35:08)

Comedy is really interesting in the way of like just speak to what you know. And if you have a joke that involves another demographic, like please pitch it and pass the baton to somebody else. maybe they can make better sense of that from their lived experience there's more opportunity

to be smarter, be better, be more vigilant about what you want to put out there and why. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.

Joe Mantello (35:22)

To be smarter, be better, be more vigilant about what you want out there and why. Yeah, yeah.

But I think this is the interesting, going back to the Bruce of it all, I think he is. There are things that are said in this play that are pretty shocking, right? But it's intentional, it's meant to push your buttons, it's meant to challenge you. Yeah. And

Mikayla (35:28)

this is the interesting going back to the Bruce of it all, I think is there are things that are said in this play that are pretty shocking. Yeah. But it's intentional. It's meant to push your buttons. It's meant to challenge you. Yeah. And

Joe Mantello (35:46)

I don't know, I mean, I

Mikayla (35:46)

I don't know. I mean I

I it's a bigger conversation, but you know, in the last few years

Joe Mantello (35:48)

I it's a bigger conversation, but you know, in the last few years,

Rehearsal rooms have become a different. There's the landscape of a rehearsal room is different, right? It's much different. Well, I think people are very careful and they think they should be careful. I also think that a certain amount of conflict is the wrong word, but challenge of one another is is is good in when you're making something. And that

Mikayla (35:53)

Rehearsal rooms have become a different, there's the landscape of the rehearsal room is different, right? Tell me more. Well, I think people are very careful and they think they should be careful. Okay. I also think that a certain amount of conflict is the wrong word, but challenge of one another is is is good in when you're making something. Yeah. And

Joe Mantello (36:18)

I think there's a difference between

Mikayla (36:18)

I think there's a difference between

a respectful room and a polite room. Cheers, yeah. Mm-hmm. And when it's just a kind of politeness, and in my experience, sometimes a performative politeness. Mm-hmm. Okay. Yep. as opposed to, you know, I don't have a problem with an actor disagreeing with me. And I hope,

Joe Mantello (36:19)

A respectful room and a polite room. Cheers, yeah. And when it's just a kind of politeness and in my experience, sometimes a performative politeness. as opposed to, you know, I don't have a problem with an actor disagreeing with me. And I hope,

you know, I think that can lead sometimes to

Mikayla (36:43)

You know, I think that can lead sometimes to

an actor and a director having different points of view can actually lead you to a different and a more exciting choice that you make together. Yes. But that tension or that push and pull between the two people who are making it in the room, I think is good.

Joe Mantello (36:45)

an actor and a director having different points of view can actually lead you to a different an and a more exciting choice that you make together. But that tension or that push and pull between the two people who are making it in the room, I think is good.

And I think it has to be respectful, right? I think it has to be always has to be respectful. But I don't think people have to agree.

Mikayla (37:03)

And I think it has to be respectful, right? Sure. Always has to be respectful. But I don't think people have to agree.

No, and I think that you're cultivating a room of people that are professionals that can be trusted with their energy and their vulnerability and their trust with one another. So if you're in that safe space in the rehearsal room, like please share what you're really thinking. So you can get underneath that and then use that in a way that is safe so it doesn't maybe come out later in the process or on stage. I mean, you never know how

people

Joe Mantello (37:17)

in that safe space in the rehearsal room, like please share what you're really thinking. Share what you're thinking. Get underneath that and then use that in a way that is safe so it doesn't maybe come out later in the process or on stage. I mean you never know how people

feel about this subject matter or what it will evoke for them.

Mikayla (37:31)

feel about this subject matter or what it will evoke for them on

stage. What do you do as a director? Like what is your directing style? Do you come in with a specific vision or is this all sorted out through collaboration in process these characters I it I come in very prepared. Okay. Meaning that, you know, I sort of know the script backwards and forwards. I spent a lot of time with it, not only through the design process, but just on my own and I'll, you know, and I

Joe Mantello (37:35)

Stage. What do you do as a director? Like what is your directing style? Do you come in with a specific vision or is this all sorted out through collaboration in process off what It's sorta it's I it I come in very prepared, meaning that, you know, I sort of know the script backwards and forwards. I spent a lot of time with it, not only through the design process, but just on my own and I'll you know, and I

I'll have a notebook that I write things down, but I don't come in with a plan in place because I think at least the way that I work that

Mikayla (38:00)

down but I don't come in with a plan in place because I think at least the way that I work that

Joe Mantello (38:07)

I don't dupe actors into doing my vision of the play. I think we're all together and the play, certainly in like something like Death of a Salesman, reflected I had some ideas, I had some big ideas conceptually about what I wanted to do, but but we made the company and I and the designers, we made that together and it's a reflection of all of us.

Mikayla (38:07)

I don't dupe actors into doing my vision of the play. I think we're all together and the play, certainly in like something like Death of a Salesman, reflected I had some ideas, I had some big ideas conceptually about what I wanted to do. But but we made the the company and I and the designers we made that together and it's a reflection of all of us. Yeah.

Joe Mantello (38:28)

And we went down lots of dead ends and we just experimented. So in that particular case, I had an idea of something, but I didn't know how we were going to execute it. And I said that to the company on the first day. I was like, We're gonna

Mikayla (38:29)

We went down lots of dead ends and we just experimented.

So in that particular case I had an idea of something, but I didn't know how we were going to execute it. And I said that to c company on the first day. I was like, we're gonna

Joe Mantello (38:43)

we're gonna make some huge mistakes, but I wanna take a big swing at this.

Mikayla (38:43)

We're gonna make some huge mistakes. But I wanna take a big swing of this. I you have to take big swings.

my goodness. that reminds me of improv and comedy too, in the way that

Joe Mantello (38:52)

And the way that

Mikayla (38:53)

you can never be more prepared and then you need to throw it all away. But you need to have the baseline in the back of your head so you know exactly when you're gonna break a rule, you know exactly when you're listening to your partner to say, this is when I'm going to totally debra everything I had in mind in service of what is happening right here,

Joe Mantello (38:56)

All away. But you need to have the baseline in the back of your head so you know exactly when you're gonna break a rule, you know exactly when you're listening to your partner to say, this is when I'm going to totally derail everything I had in mind in service of what is happening right here.

Mikayla (39:11)

right now.

Joe Mantello (39:11)

Yeah. But just having the blueprint so you so valuable. I was talking to Moisess Kaufman

Mikayla (39:12)

But just having the blueprint so you can then alter it, I think is so valuable.

Joe Mantello (39:17)

the other day. We were doing a we were having a conversation and we were talking about this very thing and said he we were talking about he said, What is your process? And we sort of we came to the understanding that we both approached the work the same way and he said, I think it was Peter Hall he said, talked about it that he does a lot of work, a lot of research, but then he comes into the room with a hunch.

Mikayla (39:19)

conversation. Yeah. We were talking about this very thing and said he we were talking about he said, What is your process? And we sort of we came to the understanding that we both approach the work the same way and he said, I think it was Peter Hall he said, talked about it, that he does a lot of work, a lot of research, but then he comes into the room with a hunch. Mm.

Okay. And I thought, that's exactly what it is. I have a punch about this. Yes. Ooh, I

Joe Mantello (39:38)

And I thought, that's exactly what it is. I have a hunch about this. Yes. Yeah. Ooh.

I love that phrasing. I might steal it. Yeah, yeah. It's so true. That is what it is. But I think there are other people who

Mikayla (39:43)

I love that phrasing. I might steal that. No, that's so true.

Joe Mantello (39:49)

come in and they have a really they've got a vision for it and that, you know, and they know exactly what it's going to look like and the act and so it's a different kind of an experience. Yeah, that tracks. Okay, that leads me to my

Mikayla (39:52)

You know, they know exactly what it's going to look like. Right. Yeah. And it's so it's a different kind of an experience. Yeah, that checks. Okay, that leads me to my

one and only Wicked question. I for a show that is running that long, is it something like when I was at Sleep No More, we would have rehearsal directors that would come in and just make sure the vision of the show and the integrity is in shape, but the director director would maybe like once a year pop in and see how things are going. Is that similar to Wicked? Or is that are you kind of

Joe Mantello (40:03)

Okay. I for a show that is running that long, is it something like when I was at Sleep No More, we would have rehearsal directors that would come in and just make sure the vision of the show and the integrity is in shape, but the director director would maybe like once a year pop in and see how things are going. Is that similar to Wicked, or is that are you kind of

in the room more often, or do you?

Mikayla (40:22)

in the room more often or do you

let it live with the team that you trust? How does that process work for

Joe Mantello (40:25)

How does that process work for

well we're over 20 years into it at this point? And so

Mikayla (40:29)

Yeah, it's like

Joe Mantello (40:31)

there's a really I mean there's a heroic team of people who maintain the show. they've all been there from day one. So they understand the impulses behind the scenes and the songs. and they do an incredible job and they're

Mikayla (40:37)

They've all been there from day one, so they understand the impulses behind the scenes and the songs. and they do an incredible job and they're

devoted and

Joe Mantello (40:48)

devoted and

you know we all made a decision early on you know something like wicked comes around once in a lifetime right and we're incredibly fortunate that that

Mikayla (40:50)

You know, we all made a decision early on. You know, something like wicked comes around once in a lifetime, right? And we're incredibly fortunate that that

Joe Mantello (40:59)

we had that happen to us and I've always said like I think we have a responsibility

Mikayla (41:01)

To us. And I've always said, like, I think we have a responsibility

as much as we possibly can, as much as humanly possible, to deliver a show that is as fresh and alive as it was when Idina and Kristen were in it. I mean, sometimes it's sometimes it is and sometimes it isn't, but certainly that is the impulse behind it. Sure. And

Joe Mantello (41:06)

as much as we possibly can, as much as humanly possible, to deliver a show that is as fresh and alive as it was when Idina and Kristen were in it. I mean sometimes it's sometimes it is and sometimes it isn't, but certainly that is the impulse behind it. And

so no one is

Mikayla (41:25)

So no one is

consciously phoning it in. Like we really and in answer to your question, I see any actor that's being considered for the principal, I will get a tape at this point. Fair I see them I see the productions maybe like twice a year. That's great. Yeah, I'm always curious about long running shows where it's like we're keeping the integrity and the freshness, as you said, alive, but then speaking to process in the rehearsal room, I think

Joe Mantello (41:27)

Consciously phoning it in. Like we really and in answer to your question, I see any actor that's being considered for the principal, I will get a tape at this point. And then I see them I see the productions maybe like twice a year. That's great. Yeah. Yeah, I'm always curious about long running shows where it's like we're keeping the integrity and the freshness, as you said, alive. But then speaking to process in the rehearsal room, I think

Mikayla (41:49)

more pedestrian audiences not in theater don't always understand that your put in is maybe like you have one rehearsal for the put in and then you are on with the audience, but you're learning the show in a studio with your assistant stage manager, right? And so it's a very different process than starting from the beginning. And so keeping things fresh and bringing these different energies in and out of a contract

Joe Mantello (41:49)

Pedestrian audience is not in theater, don't always understand that your put in is maybe like you have one rehearsal for the put-in, and then you are on with the audience, but you're learning the show in the studio with your assistant stage manager, right? And so it's a very different process than starting from the beginning. So keeping things fresh and bringing these different energies in and out of a contract.

Mikayla (42:12)

over the course of such a long show, it's fascinating to see how, you know, the team holds it together and keeps it fresh.

Joe Mantello (42:11)

over the course of such a long show, it's fascinating to see how team holds it together and keeps it fresh. Well

one the things that we've learned is that it tends to be smoother

Mikayla (42:20)

Tends to be

Joe Mantello (42:22)

when we put

There were a few years where we were putting in people kind of piecemeal, like an Elphaba would go in, and then two months later a Glinda would go in, and so what we've tried to do, and we're more successful than not, but is to try to put in a team of principals so that they are going in together as a group. and that seems to have make a huge difference. The tricky part is that

Mikayla (42:24)

There were a few years where we were putting in people kind of piecemeal, like an alphabet would go in, and then two months later a Glinda would go in, and so what we've tried to do, and we're more successful than not, but is to try to put in a team of principals so that they are going in together as a group. and that seems to have make a huge difference. The tricky part is that

Joe Mantello (42:46)

You don't want it to be a carbon copy and yet you've got two weeks, right? Two weeks, maybe three, but you know, and so I always say to the associates, like, look, someone can't change the staging and be standing where there's no light. How they get there or what the impulse is behind it, I don't

Mikayla (42:46)

You don't want it to be a carbon copy, and yet you've got two weeks, right? Yeah. Two weeks, maybe three. But you know, and so I always say to the associates, like, look, someone can't change the staging and standing where there's no light. Right. How they get there or what the impulse is behind it, I don't

Joe Mantello (43:04)

care as long as it feels right. There's a certain amount of leeway, but

Mikayla (43:05)

care as long as it feels right. Right. There's a certain amount of leeway, but

that's hard f that's a hard judgment call to make in that moment for the associates because it's like, I don't know, is this but

Joe Mantello (43:09)

That's hard f that's a hard judgment call to make in that moment for the associates because it's like, I don't know, is this but

Mikayla (43:16)

And that's comparable to what we said before where then it's the actor's job and granted like these auditions come up so hard and so fast that you know you can't prepare

Joe Mantello (43:20)

like these auditions come up so hard and so fast that you know you can't prepare

Mikayla (43:24)

your life for like maybe getting a call for a show like that.

Joe Mantello (43:26)

Right.

But just to say like come in with the strongest choice you can. You know if that's gonna work in service of the blocking, or whether it's like okay, we need to take a different direction. But at least you have something to offer the team. Yeah. Where it's like I was talking to Emma and I was like, you your Glenda reminds me so much of Kristen. So beautiful. But then there's so many moments that are just entirely her own.

Mikayla (43:27)

But just to say, like, come in with the strongest choice you can. So you know if that's gonna work in service of the blocking, or whether it's like, okay, we need to take a different direction. But at least you have something to offer the team. Yeah. Where it's like I was talking to Emma and I was like, you your Glenda reminds me so much of Kristen and it's so beautiful. But then there are so many moments that are just entirely her

own. But she came in with such strong, clear choices from what it seems. I mean, obviously, 'cause it worked out, but

Joe Mantello (43:48)

Yeah. From what it seems. I obviously, because it worked out. Yeah, yeah,

yeah. Yeah, like you need to be able to know what your energy is going to bring to this point. It's tricky, but I mean, that's exactly right. It's like,

Mikayla (43:55)

Yeah, like you need to be able to know what your energy is gonna bring to the table and how to like

Joe Mantello (44:01)

you know, because we live in a world now where all of these performances exist on YouTube, right? And so there is a there is a there is a kind

Mikayla (44:05)

exist on YouTube, right? Yeah. And so there is a there is a there is a kind

Joe Mantello (44:12)

of a

prototype of Glinda, but this is my personal feeling. I I can't speak for the under the members of the team, but yes, you have to fit in within that, but I think some of the most successful Glinda's are the ones that have found their version of there's only one Kristen Chenowith, right? I mean, she's one of one. Yeah. And you you know, and so there but we've had people along the way that have been as idiosyncratic, as funny, and you know

Mikayla (44:13)

type of Glinda. But this is my personal feeling. I I can't speak for the other members of the team, but yes, you have to fit in within that. But I think some of the most successful Glindas are the ones that have found their version of there's only one Kristen Chenowith. I mean she's one yeah you know and so there but we've had people along the way that have been as idiosyncratic as funny and you know

But they were still Glenda.

Joe Mantello (44:42)

But they were still Glinda.

Mikayla (44:43)

Right. Yeah. No one's gonna do it better than you. I know Dan Michikai was telling me he was like, You're like the Ali Malzi kinda Glenda, like the manic, like a little kind of crazy. But being able to pave the way to create these sub archetypes of like this is the type of Glenda you are per se for a long running show like this, I think is so incredible because you are bringing your whole heart and your whole spirit into this where other people can see themselves in you.

Joe Mantello (44:50)

Yeah, yeah, yeah. But being able to pave the way to create these sub-archetypes of like this is the type of Glenda UR, per se, for a long running show like this, I think is so incredible because you are bringing your whole heart and your whole spirit into this where other people can see themselves in you. Yeah,

yeah. Yeah, yeah. Is there anything that an actor has done in a rehearsal room that immediately earns your trust or has shifted the way you see a character?

Mikayla (45:05)

Yeah, I just think it's so brilliant. Is there anything that an actor has done in a rehearsal room that immediately earns your trust or has shifted the way you see a character? I mean

Joe Mantello (45:15)

I mean it it's always interesting to be

Mikayla (45:15)

it it's always interesting to

Joe Mantello (45:17)

in a room with Laurie Metcalf because she comes at things from such unexpected angles. I mean,

Mikayla (45:21)

at things from such unexpected angles. I mean,

Joe Mantello (45:25)

we've collaborated on I think eight or nine plays now. And I'm always it's so exciting to be in the room with her because I don't know any other actor who rehearses the way in which she rehearses.

Mikayla (45:28)

Now, and I'm always it's so exciting to be in the room with her because I don't know any other actor who rehearses the way in which she rehearses. Okay.

Is that she's kind of exploring the unexpected choice in a character, and that's fascinating to her. And how her mind works. So there were things about her Linda.

Joe Mantello (45:38)

Is that she's kind of exploring the unexpected choice in a character. And that's fascinating to her. And it's just where how how her mind works. So there were things about her Linda

Lohman, which were really surprising to me that I would never have expected. but they're always

Mikayla (45:53)

were really surprising to me that I would never have expected. but they're always

Joe Mantello (45:57)

I don't know, I just learned a lot from watching her. Is it fun developing friendships with these performers and then putting on your business hat and then seeing how they work as a professional in the space?

Mikayla (45:57)

I don't know, I just learned a lot from watching her. Is it fun developing friendships with these performers and then putting on your business hat and then seeing how they work as a professional in the space?

Joe Mantello (46:08)

Yeah, there's no there's no there's no membrane that separates our friendship and our artistic relationship because you know, we're both from Illinois, so Laurie has described it as we're both like Illinois clear. Like we

Mikayla (46:08)

You're incredible. There's no there's no membrane that separates our friendship and our artistic relationship because you know, we're both from Illinois, so Laurie is described as we're both like Illinois clear, like

Joe Mantello (46:20)

we approach work the same way, which is very practical. we take it seriously, but we don't take ourselves seriously.

Mikayla (46:20)

Approach work the same way, which is very practical. we take it seriously, but we don't take ourselves seriously.

we laugh at the same things. So quite often rehearsal with Laurie is about just throwing ideas back and forth, like I'll throw down a challenge for her.

Joe Mantello (46:28)

we laugh at the same things. So quite often rehearsal with Laurie is about just throwing ideas back and forth, like I'll throw down a challenge for her

Mikayla (46:38)

Yeah she'll she'll try something to make me laugh and it's very organic in that way. It's I think it's why we work together so much is just we just enjoy being in the room with one another. Right. And that's such a

Joe Mantello (46:38)

or she'll s she'll try something to make me laugh. And it's very organic in that way. It's I think it's why we've worked together so much is just we just enjoy being in the room with one another. Right. that's such a

Mikayla (46:49)

beautiful kind of friendship. my best friend is an opera stage director and we work on some projects together. And so, you know, we'll be on the phone call talking about our day and whatever,

Joe Mantello (46:51)

an opera stage director work on some projects together and so you know we'll be on the phone call talking about our day whatever

Mikayla (46:57)

and then we get on

for our meetings and just seeing the way that we see the world and see the art It's just so much fun because you're there's so much pride in like, my gosh, the the fact that you thought of that idea or the fact that you pieced together is so smart. But yeah, just the level of pride I'm sure you have in each other is great.

Joe Mantello (46:59)

seeing the way that we see the world and see the art It's just so much fun. Because there's so much pride in like, my gosh, the the fact that you thought of that idea or the fact that you pieced together is so smart. But yeah just the level of pride I'm sure you have in each other is Yeah and she's

taught me a lot. She's taught me a lot.

about always look she's always looking for the most surprising choice and so I've learned a lot from her to not just to she never kind of traffics in cliche. You know her Linda Lohman was very different than most Linda Lomans because she had a particular take on the character that

was just it's so interesting and I never I I never saw it that way. Right. We're

Mikayla (47:39)

just it's so interesting and I never I I never saw it that way. Right. I love that.

what are we getting right or wrong about nurturing the next generation of theater artists? What do you think we can do better

Joe Mantello (47:51)

You know, I was saying to someone the other day,

Mikayla (47:51)

You know, I was saying to someone the other day

Joe Mantello (47:53)

there's a younger generation of

Mikayla (47:53)

younger generation.

Joe Mantello (47:54)

directors and you know, I'm such a private person,

Mikayla (47:56)

I'm such a private person.

Joe Mantello (47:58)

you know, and I think I'm pretty open in a rehearsal room, but I don't like to

Mikayla (47:59)

I think I'm pretty open in a rehearsal room but I don't like to

Joe Mantello (48:03)

I don't like to talk about it really. And I and I don't like to

Mikayla (48:05)

Really and I don't like to

Joe Mantello (48:08)

I don't

I'm uncomfortable with self promotion. And I think there's a generation that's come up, you know,

Mikayla (48:10)

self-promotion. And I think there's a generation that's come up, you know,

Joe Mantello (48:14)

there's an openness to their process that's shared with the world. And I don't have a judgment about that. It's just antithetical to the way that I think. You know, like I could never imagine having an Instagram account where

Mikayla (48:14)

there's an openness to their process that's shared with the world. Yeah. And I don't have a judgment about that. It's just antithetical to the way that I think. Sure. Like I could never imagine having an Instagram account where I

Joe Mantello (48:27)

I gave someone access to the room or I even talked about the work. I don't think that's bad. That the people who do that, it's just it's just different. It's just really, really different. And

Mikayla (48:28)

gave someone access to the room or I even talked about the work. I don't think that's bad. That the people who do that it's just it's just different. It's just really, really different. And it is

Joe Mantello (48:39)

You know

Mikayla (48:39)

you know

Joe Mantello (48:39)

And and I think that's true for actors as well, you know, the number of people who post backstage for you know, getting ready and a again, it's just a kind of access that I don't understand. And I feel like a dinosaur, but that's how I feel. I love consuming that type of content, but when I am backstage, I'm like, I don't have time to do this. I'm like barely getting my pink curls in. I can't imagine like getting yourself into the zone and carry.

Mikayla (48:39)

And and I think that's true for actors as well. You know, the number of people who post backstage for you know, getting ready and again, it's just a kind of access that I don't understand. Right. No, it's true. I love consuming that type of content, but when I am backstage, I'm like, I don't have time to do this. I'm like barely getting my pink curls in. I can't imagine like getting yourself into the zone in character

but then also

Joe Mantello (49:07)

So

being able to make this fun content. it's part of the reason why I started this podcast because there is a pressure of if you're not a celebrity and if you're not established at a younger age, neither of which I am, how do you

Mikayla (49:08)

being able to make this fun content. time it doesn't. I actually it's part of the reason why I started this podcast because there is a pressure of, if you're not a celebrity and if you're not established at a younger age, neither of which I am, how do you

promote yourself in a way that is authentic? And what does authenticity even mean?

Joe Mantello (49:20)

yourself in a way that is authentic. What does authenticity even mean?

Mikayla (49:24)

So rather than make those types of videos or share backstage content, I'm like, I'd rather just talk about the art. And then if you, you know, happen to learn about me in the process and you like me, great. And if you don't, you never have to watch this again. But I'd rather like create content that is meaningful and helpful to an industry and the audience is consuming it than be like, get ready with me. Not to say I don't I I love watching other people's

Joe Mantello (49:24)

So rather than make those types of videos or share backstage content, I'm like, I'd rather just talk about the art. And then if you you know happen to learn about me in the process and you like me, great. And if you don't, you never have to watch this again. But I'd rather like create content that is meaningful and helpful to an industry and the audience is consuming it than be like, okay, ready with me. Not to say I don't I I love watching other people

Mikayla (49:50)

journeys and process. I just don't know that.

Joe Mantello (49:50)

Journeys and process. I don't know I have

the capacity for that either. Yeah, I mean there's a mystery to what there's a mystery to what we do, right? And that I think is valuable. But I'm of a different generation. And so, you know, one time I went and spoke to this is several years ago and it sort of led nowhere. But I said to the company Wicked on Broadway, and I said, I'm speaking for myself as the director, I'm speaking, you know.

Mikayla (49:53)

I have the capacity for that either. You know what I mean? I there's a mystery to what we do, right? I think is valuable. But I'm of a different generation. And so, you know, one time I went and spoke to this is several years ago and it sort of led nowhere. But I said to the company Wicked on Broadway, and I said, I'm speaking for myself as the director, I'm speaking, you know,

Joe Mantello (50:18)

I'm not a representative of the producers or anyone else. I I'm asking you respectfully when you post from back well, first of all, keep your head in the show, right? Right, right, right. Keep your head in the show. It's three hours, right? so that's number one. Number two, please don't post yourself in costume doing something that the character wouldn't do.

Mikayla (50:18)

I'm not a representative of the producers or anyone else. Sure. I I'm asking you respectfully, when you post from back well, first of all, keep your head in the show, right? Right, right, right. Keep your head in the show. It's three hours. Okay. Yeah. so that's number one. Number two, please don't post yourself in costume doing something that the character wouldn't do.

Joe Mantello (50:44)

you are the steward of this character for the moment, but the character lives beyond you. And if you're Elphaba and you're twerking as you're getting ready or at intermission. I just I don't understand that. Because and the response was, and it was and I took them seriously, you don't understand. we get a lot of pressure from our reps to build

Mikayla (50:45)

Steward of this character for the moment, but the character lives beyond you. And if you're alphabet and you're twerking, as you're getting ready or at intermission, I just I don't understand that because and the response was, and it was and I took them seriously. You don't understand. we get a lot of pressure from our reps to build.

Joe Mantello (51:10)

You know, a kind of a social media to to build followers like that, that's important. We're keep hearing that that's important. So this is one way to do it that the fans want access.

Mikayla (51:10)

you know, a kind of a social media to to build followers. Sure. That's important. We're to keep hearing that that's important. So this is one way to do it that the fans want access.

Yes. And also the relatability of like, look at this silly video of Elphaba Betwerking.

Joe Mantello (51:24)

Silly video of alphabet.

Mikayla (51:26)

Like there's a dissonance between the character and the pop culture that is inherently funny and can drive engagement. But where's the line between

Joe Mantello (51:26)

There's a dissonance between the character and the pop culture that is inherently funny and can drive engagement, but where is a line between,

you know, I'm giving you a glimpse into this access and this parasocial relationship without compromising the integrity of the magic of the characters you've made. Yep. Yeah. Yeah. That's a really like. Yeah, I mean you if you see an if you see an

Mikayla (51:34)

You know, I'm giving you a glimpse into this access and this parasocial relationship without compromising the integrity of the magic of the characters you've made. Yeah, that's a really hard line to walk.

Joe Mantello (51:46)

actor p specific specifically playing Elphaba and you see that the makeup only goes to their and they're in their, you know, a t shirt or a bra

Mikayla (51:47)

Specifically playing Elphaba, and you see that the makeup only goes to and they're in their, you know, a t-shirt or a bra,

and you and it's like it's like the magic trick is revealed. Right. And the magic's not that complicated to begin with, but you know what I mean? Right. And that I think is I wish that that I wish that that wasn't so much.

Joe Mantello (51:55)

And you know, and and it's like it's like the magic trick is revealed. And the magic's not that complicated to begin with, but you know what I mean? It's like, and that I think is I wish that that I wish that that wasn't so much

a

part of the creative process, but I accept that it is. And you know, I just feel like

Mikayla (52:12)

A part of the creative process, but I accept that it is. And sure. you know, I just feel like

my work will speak for itself and you either engage with it or you don't. And

Joe Mantello (52:19)

my work will speak for itself and you either engage with it or you don't and

Mikayla (52:24)

cheers. Yeah. I hope that we hit some sort of a head with the digital realm and we go back to an analog state. That would be so wonderful. I don't think that we will, but I do think that there is at least a craving to get back.

Joe Mantello (52:32)

I'm not sure. I don't I don't think that we will I don't think so. I do think that there is at least a craving to get back

to like human to human connection and that's where theater plays in. So gosh, yeah, I don't know where we're going with it. But let me ask you your last question. Okay. When people look back on your body of work fifty years from

Mikayla (52:38)

to like human to human connection and that's where theater plays in. So gosh, yeah, I don't know where we're going with it. But let me ask you your last question. When people look back on your body of work fifty years from now

or however long from now, what do you hope they understand about the kind of stories that you chose to tell?

Joe Mantello (52:55)

gosh, that's such a hard question. What do I because it's because it

Mikayla (52:57)

I know.

Joe Mantello (52:59)

it implies that I have it that it's considered and that I have an overview. It's hard to overview when you're so close to it as well. Yeah. And there's no I there's no pattern in it. I mean, there's not

Mikayla (53:01)

it's considered and that I have an overview. Yeah, it's hard to overview when you're so close to it as well. I guess there's no there's no pattern in it. Yeah. There's not

Joe Mantello (53:11)

I think the work that I've done over the years is very, very different. I mean I think.

Mikayla (53:13)

is very, very is very different. I mean I think

I hope people think that, they saw that I tried to tell stories honestly and passionately and from my heart. in whatever form that they were ultimately

Joe Mantello (53:17)

I hope people think that, they saw that I tried to tell stories honestly and passionately and from my heart. in whatever form that they were ultimately

that they ultimately took. I just I don't know what the pattern is. maybe someone that's much smarter than I am will be able to look and say, Well, this is the common denominator in the work.

Mikayla (53:27)

ultimately took. Yeah. I I don't know what the pattern is. maybe someone that's much smarter than I am will be able to look and say, well this is the the common denominator in the work.

Right. Well you can't possibly self-analyze yourself to that level. That's crazy. But just to say, you know what is the general theme of what you want to leave behind, which is telling stories honestly. So you answer that. You answer that well. my gosh. Okay. Thank you so much for coming on. This is great.

Joe Mantello (53:37)

Possibly self-analyze yourself to that level, that's crazy. But just to say, you what is the general theme of what you want to leave behind, which is telling stories honestly. So you answer that. Okay, yeah, okay, yeah, good. Thank you so much for coming on. Thank you for having me. It was nice to

meet you.

Mikayla (53:52)

Nice meet you

Thank you for doing this.

Joe Mantello (53:52)

Thank you so much.

Mikayla Petrilla (53:54)

And that was tea time with Joe Mantello.

What I keep coming back to is Joe's willingness to sit with a question, to let a story challenge him, and to leave room for his own understanding to change. I think we can learn so much from that. There was something incredibly generous in that, both as an artist and as a person. Joe, thank you for coming on and for being so warm, thoughtful, and open. This is a conversation I'll be thinking about for a long time. you're just so cool and down to earth and direct, and I appreciate your perspective so much.

if you, the audience, have seen Down State, I would love to hear about what stayed with you. What questions did you carry home and are you still wrestling with them?

For more conversations, about the art we make and the lives behind it, follow tea time wherever you listen or you can subscribe on YouTube. Thank you for spending your time with me and I will see you next time.

© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved

An error occurred